Some of us will remember how Ted Stevens, chairman of the Senate Commerce Committee and in charge of regulating the Internet, demonstrated his grasp of the technology: It’s not like a big truck. It’s a series of tubes. Now he’s defending himself:
“I have a letter from a big scientist who said I was absolutely right in using the word ‘tubes,”‘ he told reporters.
I wonder how big that scientist was? 300 lbs maybe? He’d have to be pretty big to cover for Stevens’s ignorance.
Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.
RSATo be honest rather than snarky, I think it’s not too bad an analogy either; we sometimes talk about information being pipelined, etc., so it’s not a priori ridiculous. But to introduce the tubes analogy as a better one that a truck analogy, I think, shows a basic lack of understanding. He’d have been better off saying it’s like telephone lines with everyone talking to everyone all the time.
Unless otherwise specified, all content is made available under the Creative Commons License.
I thought Stevens was hilarious, but - and maybe this is my own ignorance - I thought it wasn’t too bad as an analogy. I don’t know about a “series” of tubes, rather a network of tubes, many running in parallel. Of course, his prime objective was to let Ma Bell decide which packets move & which ones sit, so they can charge more for moving them… which is a stupid idea. But, really one can do worse than the tubes analogy… tubes with a bunch of dump trucks driving through them, maybe.